1205 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106, Pasadena, 91106 - 4 bed, 3 bath

1205 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$4,200,000
1205 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106
4Beds
3Baths
3,832Sqft
31,925Lot
Year Built
1915
Close
-
List price
$4.2M
Original List price
$4.2M
Price/Sqft
$1,096
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
P1-24176
Home ConditionPoor
Features
Patio
View-

About this home

Fairly Priced:The estimated price is in line with the list price. We found 3 Cons,5 Pros. Rank: price - $4.20M(74th), sqft - 3832(74th), beds - 4(50th), baths - 3(50th).

*Fixer Opportunity* Presenting The Arthur Byrne House, a rare and unique opportunity to bring this property back to its former glory. With its historic integrity, the home provides an excellent foundation to be reimagined and tailored into your personal vision of a dream residence. Located on a desirable corner lot along South Oakland Avenue, this architecturally significant Pueblo Revival style home was designed in 1915 by architect Henry Banfield. With the added benefit of the Mills Act designation, new owners can enjoy substantial property tax savings while preserving and enhancing the home's historic character. The residence offers generous square footage, a central courtyard and superb period details throughout. Notable highlights include an original Batchelder tile fireplace in the living room, a tasteful library/study with an exquisite fireplace, hardwood floors, decorative tile, and a striking Pueblo inspired exterior. Outdoors, the landscaping was awarded by the Pasadena Beautiful Foundation. The expansive grounds are truly remarkable with multiple garage spaces that feature a three-car garage, plus a bonus garage ideal for storage, workshops, or additional vehicles. The oversized lot and prominent location further add to its long-term value. Rarely does a property of this architectural pedigree, scale, and location become available. It offers the chance to combine historic character with your own design choices, creating a truly special home in one of Pasadena's most sought-after neighborhoods.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
09/18/25
Listing
$4,200,000
Condition Rating
Poor

This property, built in 1915, is explicitly marketed as a 'Fixer Opportunity' needing to be brought 'back to its former glory.' While it boasts historic integrity and charming period details like hardwood floors and Batchelder tile fireplaces, the overall condition suggests substantial rehabilitation is required. The kitchen, though functional, is significantly dated with older appliances (mixed stainless steel fridge, older black dishwasher, dated microwave) and cabinet styles that are not current. The absence of bathroom images, combined with the property's age and 'fixer' status, strongly indicates these areas would also require full renovation. Major systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC) are almost certainly original or very old and would need extensive upgrades to meet modern standards and safety. The property is habitable but requires significant investment to update and modernize, aligning with the 'poor' condition criteria.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Historic & Architectural Significance: The Arthur Byrne House, designed by Henry Banfield in 1915, is an architecturally significant Pueblo Revival style home with strong historic integrity, offering a unique piece of Pasadena's heritage.
Mills Act Designation: The property benefits from a Mills Act designation, providing new owners with substantial property tax savings, a significant financial advantage for preserving its historic character.
Prime Location & Expansive Lot: Located on a desirable corner lot in one of Pasadena's most sought-after neighborhoods, the property boasts an oversized 31,925 sqft lot, adding to its long-term value and appeal.
Unique Period Details: The residence features superb period details throughout, including an original Batchelder tile fireplace, a tasteful library/study with an exquisite fireplace, hardwood floors, decorative tile, and a striking Pueblo-inspired exterior.
Extensive Garage Space: The property offers remarkable grounds with multiple garage spaces, including a three-car garage plus a bonus garage, ideal for storage, workshops, or additional vehicles.

Cons

Fixer Opportunity: Explicitly marketed as a 'Fixer Opportunity,' the property requires significant renovation and investment to restore it to its former glory, appealing primarily to buyers seeking a restoration project.
Potential for High Renovation Costs: Given its 1915 construction and 'fixer' status, buyers should anticipate substantial costs for necessary updates to systems, infrastructure, and general modernization beyond the purchase price.
Limited Buyer Pool: The combination of its historic nature, 'as-is' condition, and the implied renovation commitment may narrow the potential buyer pool to those with specific interest in historic preservation and significant financial resources.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state