202 Hollister Avenue, Capitola, California 95010, Capitola, - bed, bath

home-pic
ACTIVE$1,495,000
202 Hollister Avenue, Capitola, California 95010
2Beds
2Baths
1,008Sqft
2,642Lot
Year Built
1938
Close
-
List price
$1.5M
Original List price
$1.5M
Price/Sqft
-
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
ML82009938
Home ConditionFair
Features
Excellent View:
View-

About this home

Capitola Depot Hill. For generations, these colorful Capitola beach cabins have hosted family beach vacations. Located in a prime location on Depot Hill, overlooking Capitola & the Monterey Bay. Now two of these unique memory-makers are available for sale on one parcel & the third cabin is being sold separately on a separate parcel. Parcel 20 features 2 cabins 504 SF each & Parcel 19 features one cabin, 504 SF. Two light-filled structures have 2 bedrooms, bath, kitchen, & living area, w/ decorative beach house touches like wainscoting throughout. The third structure is open to the studs, ready for demolition & rebuilding. At this incredible location, you also might envision a different style of beach living, now or in the future. The cabins look and feel historic, but they don't have that official designation, so you are free to update and/or replace them with your dream beach house. From this sunny spot, the possibilities are truly endless. Either way, keeping the cabins as they are or build a new beach home, you'll be living in one of the most coveted places on the entire Pacific coastline. Capitola draws visitors from all over the world. Heres your opportunity to be more than a visitor: a resident of this very special place, creating new memories for generations to come.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
06/05/25
Listing
$1,495,000
Neighborhood Comparison

 SubjectAverage HomeNeighbourhood Ranking (27 Listings)
Beds23
25%
Baths22
50%
Square foot1,0081,574
14%
Lot Size2,6425,031
18%
Price$1.5M$1.7M
21%
Price per square foot$1,483$1,141.5
89%
Built year19389830985
18%
HOA
Days on market153151
50%
Condition Rating
Fair

The property, built in 1938, consists of two small cabins that are functional but significantly outdated. The kitchen features old white appliances, basic cabinets, and dated laminate countertops. Light fixtures are very basic, and heating is provided by an older wall-mounted unit. While the carpet appears clean and there's fresh paint and wainscoting, indicating some upkeep, the core components and overall style are clearly from an older era and require substantial updates to meet modern standards. The visible surface-mounted electrical wiring also points to an older system. The property is livable but requires minor updates and repairs to modernize and improve comfort, aligning with the 'Fair' condition criteria.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional Coastal Location: The property boasts a prime location on Depot Hill, offering views of Capitola and Monterey Bay, and is situated in one of the most coveted places on the Pacific coastline.
Significant Development Potential: Without official historic designation, the property offers immense flexibility to update, replace, or build a new dream beach house, providing endless possibilities for customization.
Multi-Unit Configuration: The parcel includes two separate 504 sqft cabins, providing versatile options for rental income, guest accommodations, or multi-generational living arrangements.
Desirable Tourist Destination: Located in Capitola, a globally recognized tourist destination, the property benefits from high demand, enhancing its rental potential and long-term investment value.
Historic Charm with Renovation Freedom: The cabins retain a historic aesthetic with decorative touches like wainscoting, yet their lack of official designation allows for modernization without restrictive preservation mandates.

Cons

Age and Implied Renovation Needs: Built in 1938, the cabins, despite their charm, will likely require substantial investment for modernization, system upgrades, and potential structural improvements to meet contemporary living standards.
Small Individual Unit Footprint: Each cabin is only 504 square feet, which is a relatively small living space, potentially limiting appeal to buyers seeking more spacious accommodations or larger families.
Limited Lot Size: The 2,642 sqft lot, while accommodating two cabins, offers restricted outdoor space and may limit significant expansion beyond the existing structures.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse market stats by State