GetMyHome
‪(213) 433-7766‬

254 Rogers Avenue, Watsonville, California 95076, Watsonville, - bed, bath

home-pic
ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT$899,000
254 Rogers Avenue, Watsonville, California 95076
5Beds
3Baths
2,255Sqft
8,407Lot
Year Built
1965
Close
-
List price
$899K
Original List price
$1.05M
Price/Sqft
-
HOA
-
Days on market
69 Days
Sold On
2025-11-17
MLS number
ML82020824
Home ConditionPoor
Features
Patio
View-

About this home

This beautiful two-story home boasts approximately 2200 square feet and is located in the highly sought after Martinelli Brewington neighborhood. It features 5 bedrooms and 3 full baths, a family room with fireplace, living room and dining rooms with an attached two car garage. The lush, expansive backyard features mature trees, wisteria and abundant privacy. The nearby amenities include local parks, the East Lake Village shopping center with the amazing Staff of Life grocery store, great restaurants and the Fruition brewery! Lovingly built and maintained by one family, first time EVER on the market. Don't miss this opportunity to own one of Watsonville's exceptional classic homes. This property is just waiting for your updates and finishing touches to create your perfect dream home.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
10/11/25
Price Change
$899,000-9.6%
09/23/25
Price Change
$995,000-5.1%
09/09/25
Listing
$1,049,000
Neighborhood Comparison
 SubjectAverage HomeNeighbourhood Ranking (81 Listings)
Beds53
95%
Baths32
63%
Square foot2,2551,634
79%
Lot Size8,40711,391
40%
Price$899K$894K
50%
Price per square foot$399$552
7%
Built year19659875988
37%
HOA
Days on market57157
4%
Condition Rating
Poor
This property, built in 1965, is 59 years old and shows minimal to no significant renovations since its original construction, as indicated by the listing description and visual evidence. The kitchen features highly outdated wood cabinets, tile countertops, and older black appliances, requiring a complete overhaul. Both bathrooms are also extremely dated with original-style vanities, tile, and wallpaper, necessitating full renovations. While the property appears structurally sound and livable, the critical areas of the kitchen and bathrooms, along with other fixtures and finishes throughout, require substantial rehabilitation to meet modern standards. The description itself states the property is 'just waiting for your updates and finishing touches,' confirming the need for significant investment.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Prime Location & Amenities: Located in the highly sought-after Martinelli Brewington neighborhood, offering convenient access to local parks, the East Lake Village shopping center, Staff of Life grocery, great restaurants, and a brewery.
Generous Living Space: Boasts approximately 2255 square feet with 5 bedrooms and 3 full baths, providing ample space for a large family or flexible living arrangements.
Private & Expansive Backyard: Features a lush, expansive backyard with mature trees and wisteria, offering abundant privacy and an ideal setting for outdoor enjoyment.
Functional Layout: Includes distinct living, dining, and family rooms with a fireplace, along with an attached two-car garage, enhancing daily functionality and convenience.
Unique Market Opportunity: Being offered for the first time ever on the market and lovingly maintained by one family, presenting a rare opportunity to acquire a classic home with character.

Cons

Requires Significant Updates: The property explicitly states it 'is just waiting for your updates and finishing touches,' indicating a need for substantial renovation and modernization to meet current standards.
Overpriced Relative to Valuation: The current list price of $899,000 is significantly higher than the estimated property value of $797,177, suggesting it may be overvalued in its present condition.
History of Price Reductions: Multiple price drops from an original list price of $1.049M to $899K signal market resistance and potential overpricing from the initial listing.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse market stats by State