GetMyHome
‪(213) 433-7766‬

309 Oaklawn Avenue, South Pasadena, California 91030, South Pasadena, 91030 - 5 bed, 3 bath

309 Oaklawn Avenue, South Pasadena, California 91030 home-pic-0
ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT$3,145,000
309 Oaklawn Avenue, South Pasadena, California 91030
5Beds
3Baths
3,629Sqft
15,311Lot
Year Built
1909
Close
-
List price
$3.15M
Original List price
$3.29M
Price/Sqft
$867
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
P1-23538
Home ConditionPoor
Features
View-

About this home

The Shimmin House. 1909. G. Lawrence Stimson, architect. This is an incredible chance to be the next steward to bring this classic historic example of an early Arts and Crafts estate into the 21st century. Located in the Oaklawn Park area of South Pasadena between the Greene and Greene designed stone entrance portal and their Oaklawn bridge, sits this majestic Craftsman time capsule ready for its next chapter. The home retains virtually all its original details including fine wood finishes, ceiling beams with integrated light fixtures, wall sconces, and two fireplaces. On the main level there is a large living room with adjoining library/den, powder room, an ample formal dining room, kitchen and laundry room. The upper level includes five bedrooms, two additional baths, and an attached enclosed sunporch. There is a large, detached garage at the rear of the 15,000+ sf property. Truly a unique opportunity. Convenient to local shopping and transportation. And don't forget the award-winning South Pasadena School District.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
08/30/25
Price Change
$3,145,000-4.6%
08/02/25
$3,295,000
Condition Rating
Poor
This 1909 Craftsman home, while architecturally significant and retaining many original details, is explicitly described as needing to be 'brought into the 21st century.' The kitchen features basic, dated cabinets and countertops, with some newer but not high-end appliances, suggesting an older, partial renovation. All three bathrooms are severely outdated with original or very old fixtures and finishes, requiring complete renovation. Given the age of the property and the lack of comprehensive modern updates, major systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC) are highly likely to be original or very old, necessitating substantial repairs and rehabilitation to meet current safety, comfort, and functional standards. This aligns with the 'poor' condition criteria, indicating a need for extensive system replacements and significant renovation beyond minor updates.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Historic Significance & Architecture: A rare opportunity to own 'The Shimmin House,' a classic 1909 Arts and Crafts estate designed by G. Lawrence Stimson, offering unique architectural value.
Preserved Original Details: The home retains virtually all its original details, including fine wood finishes, ceiling beams with integrated light fixtures, wall sconces, and two fireplaces, appealing to period enthusiasts.
Prime Location: Situated in the desirable Oaklawn Park area of South Pasadena, known for its historic charm and proximity to Greene and Greene designed landmarks.
Excellent School District: Benefits from the highly-regarded, award-winning South Pasadena School District, a significant draw for families.
Generous Lot Size & Space: Boasts a substantial 15,000+ sq ft property with a large, detached garage and ample interior space including five bedrooms and formal living areas.

Cons

Extensive Renovation Required: The property is described as a 'time capsule ready for its next chapter' and needing to be brought 'into the 21st century,' indicating a significant investment will be required for modernization and updates.
High Maintenance Demands: As a historic home built in 1909 with original details, it will likely incur higher and specialized maintenance costs compared to newer properties.
Potential Lack of Modern Amenities: While rich in historic charm, the description does not mention modern comforts such as central air conditioning or updated kitchens/bathrooms, which may be expected by buyers at this price point.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state