31959 Carroll Avenue, Hayward, California 94544, Hayward, - bed, bath

home-pic
ACTIVE$759,000
31959 Carroll Avenue, Hayward, California 94544
3Beds
2Baths
1,437Sqft
6,250Lot
Year Built
1951
Close
-
List price
$759K
Original List price
$759K
Price/Sqft
-
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
ML82026173
Home ConditionFair
Features
Patio
View-

About this home

Welcome to this charming home located in the sought-after Fairway Park neighborhood in the vibrant city of Hayward. This residence offers a comfortable living space with 1,437 sq ft, featuring three bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The heart of the home is the well-appointed kitchen, perfect for preparing meals and entertaining guests. Enjoy the ease of maintenance and modern look with laminate flooring throughout the living areas Additionally, the property includes a convenient dining area, ideal for family meals. For your laundry needs, the home provides the necessary space for efficient handling. Located within the New Haven Unified School District, this home offers access to local educational facilities. With a two-car garage and situated on a minimum lot size of 6,250 sq ft, this property offers both space and convenience. Don't miss the opportunity to make this delightful Hayward home your own.

Nearby schools

4/10
Hillview Crest Elementary School
Public,K-50.2mi
3/10
Treeview Elementary
Public,K-60.9mi
4/10
Cesar Chavez Middle School
Public,6-81.6mi
1/10
Cesar Chavez Middle School
Public,7-82.3mi
8/10
James Logan high school
Public,9-121.4mi
3/10
Tennyson High School
Public,9-122.7mi

Price History

Date
Event
Price
10/29/25
Listing
$759,000
Neighborhood Comparison

 SubjectAverage HomeNeighbourhood Ranking (102 Listings)
Beds33
50%
Baths22
50%
Square foot1,4371,408
54%
Lot Size6,2505,471
79%
Price$759K$890K
18%
Price per square foot$528$647
15%
Built year19511955
21%
HOA
Days on market7158
1%
Condition Rating
Fair

Built in 1951, this property has received some updates, but not an extensive renovation that would qualify it as 'Good' given its age. The kitchen features modern white shaker cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and a contemporary hood, suggesting a renovation within the last 5-15 years. One bathroom appears recently updated with a modern vanity and shower surround, while the other bathroom shows an older style vanity and shower door, likely updated 15-25 years ago. Flooring is a mix of tile in the main living areas (which appears clean but not brand new) and newer laminate/LVP in bedrooms and one bathroom. Light fixtures are also a mix of modern recessed/flush mounts and older chandeliers. Crucially, there's no explicit mention of recent updates to major systems (HVAC, plumbing, electrical, roof), which is a significant consideration for a home built in 1951. While move-in ready and well-maintained, the property's overall age and the varied age of its updates, particularly the lack of information on major system overhauls, align it with the 'Fair' category, indicating it's aged but maintained, with some components showing signs of being outdated and potential future needs for major system replacements.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Desirable Neighborhood: Located in the 'sought-after Fairway Park neighborhood' in Hayward, indicating a stable and attractive community.
Strong School Proximity & Rating: Excellent access to highly-rated Hillview Crest Elementary (0.23 miles, rating 4) and James Logan High School (1.39 miles, rating 8), appealing to families.
Potential for Immediate Equity: The listing price of $759,000 is significantly below the estimated property value of $870,496, suggesting a strong investment opportunity or potential for immediate equity.
Functional & Well-Maintained Interior: Features a 'well-appointed kitchen,' 'laminate flooring throughout the living areas' for modern aesthetics and ease of maintenance, and dedicated laundry space.
Practical Amenities & Lot Size: Includes a convenient two-car garage and a generous 6,250 sq ft lot, offering ample space and practical convenience.

Cons

Property Age: Built in 1951, the home may require updates to major systems (e.g., plumbing, electrical, roof, HVAC) that are not explicitly mentioned as being updated, potentially incurring future costs.
Mixed School Performance: While some schools are highly rated, the presence of lower-rated schools in the district (e.g., Cesar Chavez Middle School rating 1, Tennyson High School rating 3) could be a concern for some families.
Lack of Explicit HVAC Information: The property description does not mention a cooling system, which could be a significant drawback during warmer months in California and may require future installation.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse market stats by State