5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, California 94546, Castro Valley, - bed, bath

home-pic
ACTIVE$1,800,000
5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley, California 94546
5Beds
4Baths
3,214Sqft
7,113Lot
Year Built
2005
Close
-
List price
$1.8M
Original List price
$1.7M
Price/Sqft
-
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
41108283
Home ConditionGood
Features
Good View: Hills
Patio
ViewHills

About this home

Welcome to 5158 Proctor Rd, Castro Valley. A stunning 5-bed, 4-bath custom-built home offering 3,214 sq.ft. of thoughtfully designed living space. Tucked away on a private flag lot, this residence combines elegance, comfort, & convenience in one perfect package. Step inside to soaring ceilings, a formal living & dining area, ideal for entertaining. The expansive chef’s kitchen features ample counter space, premium appliances, and an open layout that flows seamlessly into the spacious family room. A full bedroom and bathroom on the main level provide the perfect setup for guests or multi-generational living. Upstairs, you’ll find four additional bedrooms, including two with ensuite baths. The luxurious primary suite boasts breathtaking views, a spa-inspired bathroom, & a generous walk-in closet. A versatile flex space upstairs offers endless possibilities—home office, study area, or media lounge. Fresh interior paint and beautiful hardwood floors throughout elevate the home’s timeless style. Enjoy a large 2 car garage & easy access to the outdoors—walk to Proctor Elementary, explore Ten Hills Trail to Lake Chabot, or play a round at Redwood Canyon Golf Course. Conveniently located near downtown, freeways, and BART, this home is perfectly positioned for both relaxation & commuting.

Nearby schools

8/10
Proctor Elementary School
Public,K-50.2mi
7/10
Vannoy Elementary School
Public,K-51.0mi
8/10
Chabot Elementary School
Public,K-51.3mi
7/10
Canyon Middle School
Public,6-81.2mi
7/10
Creekside Middle School
Public,6-81.3mi
8/10
Castro Valley High School
Public,9-121.0mi
2/10
Redwood Continuation High School
Public,9-121.3mi

Price History

Date
Event
Price
09/25/25
Price Change
$1,800,000+5.9%
08/15/25
Listing
$1,699,000
Neighborhood Comparison

 SubjectAverage HomeNeighbourhood Ranking (173 Listings)
Beds53
87%
Baths42
87%
Square foot3,2141,679
95%
Lot Size7,1136,483
61%
Price$1.8M$1.08M
97%
Price per square foot$560$685
17%
Built year20059770978
95%
HOA
Days on market81142
21%
Condition Rating
Good

Built in 2005, this property is in excellent, move-in ready condition. The description highlights 'fresh interior paint and beautiful hardwood floors throughout,' which are evident in the images. The kitchen features premium stainless steel appliances, ample counter space with granite countertops, and well-maintained dark wood cabinetry, offering a classic yet high-quality aesthetic. The primary bathroom is described as 'spa-inspired' and appears luxurious with modern fixtures, double vanities, and a separate tub and shower. All bathrooms are clean and functional. While the home is not newly built or extensively renovated within the last 5 years to meet 'Excellent' criteria, its age (19 years) combined with significant updates and meticulous maintenance places it firmly in the 'Good' category, requiring no immediate renovations.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Modern & Custom Build: Built in 2005, this custom-built home features contemporary design elements like soaring ceilings, fresh paint, hardwood floors, and an expansive chef's kitchen with premium appliances.
Versatile & Spacious Layout: Offering 3,214 sq.ft. with 5 beds and 4 baths, including a convenient main-level bedroom/bathroom for multi-generational living and a flexible upstairs space for various uses.
Strategic Location & Commuter Access: Situated on a private flag lot, providing tranquility while offering excellent proximity to downtown Castro Valley, freeways, and BART for convenient commuting.
Strong School District & Outdoor Access: Within walking distance to highly-rated Proctor Elementary (8/10) and close to other good schools, plus easy access to recreational areas like Ten Hills Trail and Redwood Canyon Golf Course.
Desirable Views: The luxurious primary suite boasts 'breathtaking views' of the hills, enhancing the property's aesthetic appeal and value.

Cons

Flag Lot Configuration: While offering privacy, the property's flag lot configuration may present challenges with street visibility, access, or perceived curb appeal for some buyers.
Moderate Lot Size: The 7,113 sq.ft. lot, while adequate, is not exceptionally large for a home of this square footage, potentially limiting extensive outdoor amenities or yard space.
Recent Price Increase: The property's list price recently increased from $1.699M to $1.8M, which could be perceived as an aggressive pricing adjustment by potential buyers.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse market stats by State