537 Cloverleaf Dr, Monrovia, California 91016, Monrovia, 91016 - bed, bath

537 Cloverleaf Dr, Monrovia, California 91016 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$3,980,000
537 Cloverleaf Dr, Monrovia, California 91016
0Bed
0Bath
5,073Sqft
864,776Lot
Year Built
1916
Close
-
List price
$3.98M
Original List price
$3.98M
Price/Sqft
$785
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
AR25241101
Home ConditionTear down
Features
Good View:
View-

About this home

We found 3 Cons,5 Pros. Rank: price - $3.98M(93th), sqft - 5073(93th), beds - undefined(50th), baths - undefined(50th).

This prime Monrovia foothill offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire both a quality income-producing property and a high-potential development site in one. Currently generating steady rental income with a ~3% CAP rate, the property offers substantial room for improvement and future upside. It’s ideal for investors who wish to maintain income while advancing subdivision or redevelopment plans, minimizing carrying costs during the entitlement process. The portfolio comprises two contiguous parcels: 537 Cloverleaf Dr. (APN: 8503-001-029) — approximately 4.88 acres with a 2,683 SF dwelling AND 539 Cloverleaf Dr. (APN: 8503-002-008) — approximately 14.97 acres with a 2,390 SF dwelling Together, the combined 19.85-acre property provides utilities on site. According to recent surveyor analysis, there is potential for 6 to 8 luxury single-family home lots. The optimal layout would likely include six primary lots, while two additional lots could be achieved with more complex hillside grading and retaining solutions. Set amid the natural beauty of Monrovia’s hillside neighborhoods and just minutes from Old Town Monrovia, schools, and major transportation corridors, this property blends immediate income stability with long-term development potential—a rare combination in one of the San Gabriel Valley’s most desirable submarkets. All provided information should be confirmed by any interested parties.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
10/16/25
Listing
$3,980,000
Condition Rating
Tear down

The property was built in 1916, making the structures over 100 years old. The listing description heavily emphasizes the land's development potential for 6 to 8 luxury single-family home lots, suggesting the value lies primarily in the land rather than the existing dwellings. There are no interior images provided, particularly of the kitchen and bathrooms, which is a strong indicator that these areas are in very poor, unpresentable condition. The exterior images show multiple small, dated, and neglected structures consistent with a property that has not undergone significant renovations in many decades. Given the age and the focus on redevelopment, the existing structures are likely beyond economical repair and are considered tear-downs.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Substantial Development Opportunity: The property offers significant potential for 6 to 8 luxury single-family home lots across its combined 19.85 acres, making it a prime development site.
Immediate Income Generation: Currently generates steady rental income with a ~3% CAP rate, which can help offset carrying costs during the entitlement and development phases.
Expansive Contiguous Parcels: Comprises two contiguous parcels totaling 19.85 acres, a rare and valuable asset for large-scale development in a desirable area.
Strategic Foothill Location: Situated in Monrovia's desirable foothill neighborhoods, offering natural beauty and convenient access to Old Town, schools, and major transportation corridors.
Existing On-Site Utilities: Utilities are already present on the combined 19.85-acre property, which is a significant advantage for future development planning and execution.

Cons

Advanced Age of Dwellings: The existing structures were built in 1916, suggesting they may require extensive renovation or demolition, adding to overall redevelopment costs.
Complex Hillside Development: Achieving the full 8-lot potential necessitates 'complex hillside grading and retaining solutions,' indicating potential for higher engineering and construction expenses.
Moderate Current CAP Rate: While income-producing, the ~3% CAP rate may be considered modest for investors seeking higher immediate returns, especially given the property's long-term development focus.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state