9112 Torrey Pines Road, Forest Falls, California 92339, Forest Falls, - bed, bath

home-pic
ACTIVE$333,000
9112 Torrey Pines Road, Forest Falls, California 92339
2Beds
3Baths
992Sqft
5,600Lot
Year Built
1922
Close
-
List price
$333K
Original List price
$495K
Price/Sqft
-
HOA
$145
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
SW25008834
Home ConditionFair
Features
Good View: Mountain(s), Rocks, Trees/Woods
Patio
ViewMountain(s), Rocks, Trees/Woods

About this home

GRETA GARBO & JOHN GILBERT’S LOVE NEST! They almost certainly stayed here once the 1925 “Flesh and the Devil” filming ended – they autographed the kitchen wall along w/ many others! Located in a beautiful wooded setting w/ tall cedars & oaks. There’s ~ 113 ft of street frontage for this 4-season home. It’s a perfect getaway from the May-gray, June-gloom of LA or the sweltering Palm Springs summer. The spacious rustic living rm includes a wood plank ceiling, lrg Anderson double pane wndws, stone fireplace w/ thick log mantle & redwood wainscoting. Roomy upstairs mstr bdrm has lrg wndws w/ dramatic views & ample closets. The updated kitchen is very functional & features a large fireplace w/ insert. This well-laid-out home also has a 2nd bdrm ~ 240 sqft w/ full bth. Could be used as a mother-in-law suite or as a separate unit w/ its own entrance. In winter, the house stays cozy w/ the fireplaces or 2 radiant very efficient propane heaters. Flooring is mostly stone pattern vinyl, w/ original clear-grain spruce planks upstairs. There’s also an A-shaped storage attic ~160 sqft w/ a pull-down stairway. Outside is an 11x16 storage shed. The property is very level by mtn standards, w/ some stone terracing & many hardy iris plants. There’s 2 outdoor dining areas (main garden & 1 for sunsets). 4 vehicles can street park & a loop driveway that holds ~8! It’s w/in 500 ft of Mill Creek, which can be heard in the quiet evenings. Low HOA includes water, side-road snowplowing, & a trash shed. This idyllic property is ~ 1 mi from dwntwn Forest Falls (w/ general store, gift shop, great Mexican restaurant & art gallery). The church, school & post office are ~ 1/2 mi. You’ve probably never heard of Forest Falls, because we have no lake. It also doesn’t have outrageous tourist traffic. The San Bernardino Nat’l Forest & Sand-to-Snow Nat’l Monument surround the community. Only 1 home away from Mill Creek & a hiking trail into the Nat’l Forest, its ~ a 2 mi drive to view scenic Big Falls (at 500 ft, it’s the tallest all-year waterfall in SoCal), & + 1/2 mi to Vivian Creek Trailhead to climb Mt San Gorgonio (tallest mtn in SoCal at 11,503 ft). Forest Falls has easy, safe road access ~ 20 mins to dwntwn Yucaipa & I-10, ~ 60 mins to PS. LA is ~ 80 mi away, west on Hwy 38 to Redlands, then I-10. Summer high temps ~ 85F, winter low ~15F w/ almost constant daytime sunshine during the damp, chill months of LA’s “May-grey June-gloom” and we’re ~ 20 deg cooler than PS’s sweltering summers

Price History

Date
Event
Price
09/10/25
Price Change
$333,000
01/15/25
Listing
$495,000
Neighborhood Comparison

 SubjectAverage HomeNeighbourhood Ranking (14 Listings)
Beds23
40%
Baths32
60%
Square foot9921,458
20%
Lot Size5,6007,900
13%
Price$333K$400K
27%
Price per square foot$336$256
73%
Built year19221953
7%
HOA$145
0%
Days on market294247
80%
Condition Rating
Fair

Built in 1922, this property is over 100 years old. While the description mentions an 'updated kitchen' and 'Anderson double pane windows,' the images reveal that the kitchen updates (cabinets, white appliances, backsplash) appear to be 15-25 years old, not recent. The flooring is practical vinyl, and visible light fixtures are basic and dated. There's no central AC, relying on fireplaces and propane heaters. The home is well-maintained and functional, but major components show signs of being outdated and would require minor updates to meet current aesthetic and comfort standards.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Historical Significance & Unique Charm: The property boasts a rare historical connection as a rumored 'love nest' for Greta Garbo and John Gilbert, complete with an autographed kitchen wall, offering unparalleled unique appeal.
Idyllic Mountain Retreat & Recreational Access: Nestled in a beautiful wooded setting surrounded by National Forest, it offers a serene escape from city heat, with immediate access to Mill Creek, hiking trails, and scenic waterfalls.
Versatile Living & Income Potential: Features a flexible layout with a second bedroom that can function as a separate unit or mother-in-law suite, providing potential for guest accommodation or rental income.
Year-Round Comfort & Efficiency: Equipped with multiple fireplaces and efficient radiant propane heaters, ensuring a cozy interior during winter, complemented by double-pane windows for energy efficiency.
Exceptional Parking & Accessibility: Offers extensive parking with a loop driveway accommodating up to 8 vehicles and street parking for 4, along with easy, safe road access to nearby towns and major highways.

Cons

Historic Age & Potential for System Updates: Built in 1922, while charming, the property's age suggests potential for deferred maintenance or the need for updates to core systems beyond what's explicitly mentioned.
Compact Interior Square Footage: At 992 square feet, the home offers a relatively small living space, which may limit its appeal to buyers seeking more expansive interiors or accommodating larger families.
Niche Market Appeal: The property's unique historical narrative and remote mountain location cater to a specific buyer demographic, potentially requiring a longer marketing period to find the right match.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse market stats by State